Nov. 17, 2026

Emily Oster on Parenting Anxiety, Mom Guilt & Raising Kids

Emily Oster on Parenting Anxiety, Mom Guilt & Raising Kids
Emily Oster on Parenting Anxiety, Mom Guilt & Raising Kids
The Running Wine Mom
Emily Oster on Parenting Anxiety, Mom Guilt & Raising Kids
Emily Oster on Parenting Anxiety, Mom Guilt & Raising KidsAre we making parenting harder than it needs to be?Between pregnancy rules, screen time guilt, sugar debates, and the pressure to make every parenting decision perfectly, it's no wonder so many moms feel overwhelmed.This week on The Running Wine Mom, I'm sitting down with someone whose work completely changed how I approached motherhood: Dr. Emily Oster, economist, Brown University professor, bestselling author of Expecting Better, Cribsheet, and The Family Firm, and founder of ParentData.When I was pregnant in 2020, Expecting Better was practically my Bible. In a world filled with scary headlines and endless rules, Emily's approach to understanding the actual research gave me something I desperately needed: peace of mind.And now, we're talking about everything that comes AFTER pregnancy.In this episode, Emily and I get into:
  • Parenting anxiety and mom guilt: Why one imperfect decision isn't going to ruin your child.
  • Pregnancy myths and misinformation: What inspired Expecting Better and why understanding the evidence matters.
  • Screen time and school phone bans: Why Emily supports phone-free schools and what families can do at home.
  • Holiday candy, sugar, and food rules: How to create boundaries without turning every treat into a battle.
  • Overscheduled kids: Why saying yes to every activity might mean saying no to what your family actually needs.
  • Making time for yourself: How Emily protects her love of running and why moms deserve interests outside of motherhood.
  • Evidence-based parenting: How to use research to make informed choices without letting statistics make every decision for you.
One of my favorite moments? When I asked Emily what she would tell a brand-new anxious mom, her answer was beautifully simple:"You're doing great."Sometimes that's exactly what we need to hear.Whether you're expecting your first baby, raising toddlers, or juggling school schedules and extracurricular activities, this conversation is a reminder that you don't need to parent perfectly to be a great parent.Connect with Dr. Emily OsterConnect with The Running Wine MomNew episodes every Tuesday!This conversation is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for individualized medical advice.

0:03 Welcome back to the Running Wine Mom Podcast. I'm your host, Samantha Cieslinski aka The Running Wine Mom. If you have ever been pregnant, you know sorry, hold on. If you've ever been pregnant, you know how fast the world tries to swap your intuition for a giant list of rigid rules, terrifying headlines, and pure mom guilt. But our guest today changed the entire game of this. She's an economist, professor, creator of parent data, best-selling author, and the woman who gave millions of us permission to stop panicking. To look at actual evidence and to make informed choices for our families. When I was pregnant, her groundbreaking book, Expecting Better, wasn't just a book on my nightstand. It was my absolute Bible. It replaced blankets never always mandates with real rigorous numbers.

0:47 So without further ado, let's welcome Dr. Emily Oster. Welcome to the Running Wine Mom. I am so excited to be, like I said, talking to someone who got me through. I was pregnant in Twenty twenty, so there was not a lot of social connections, and your book just really gave me so much peace. So I appreciate you writing that. That's awesome. I mean twenty twenty was a tough time for pregnancy. Yeah. so can you t for those who may not know you, can you tell everyone about yourself and how you got started in this space? Yeah. So so I'm trained as an economist. I am a professor. I'm currently at Brown.

1:29 but I got into pregnancy writing because I got pregnant. and my academic work is about data and statistical methods and health economics. When I got pregnant, I got a lot of the same rules that you got, you know, no deli meat, no smoking. And I wondered, are those similarly important? And you know, as a person who was used to using data to make decisions about my life, I was surprised at how little data there was in this space. So I started. really initially in the service of my own pregnancy and investigating, okay, what does the evidence really say? And where is the evidence good and where is it not? And that research ultimately led to my first book, Expecting Better, and then to some later books, all of which have kind of the same approach.

2:16 But I really I come into this from the academic side, but also from the personal side and trying to bring them together. And that was the one thing when what you just said that really connected me to your book because I am logistical and you know, I wanna believe what other people say too, but when you had things like written out that had the data, it made me feel so much better about making a choice or not being perfect in a lot of ways. I think What's really important about this is sometimes people will will come to me and they'll say, Okay, well, you know, are you gonna tell me what the data says to do? It's like the data doesn't say what to do. Like my work, my books, and this whole space is about saying that's one input.

3:00 And often you can make better decisions for yourself if you understand that input. If you know what is the best day to say, how do I think about the trade-offs? It can help you really make good decisions. The data isn't gonna make the decision for you. You're gonna make the decision. The data is part of your So let's go to the rules themselves, the coffee, the sushi, the deli meats, gardening, you know, the occasional glass of wine. Which one caused the biggest uproar at the time and which one were you most nervous to put in print? I think there's no question that telling people that the data says an occasional glass of wine is okay was the most controversial at the time, has remained probably the most controversial thing that I said.

3:43 And, you know, I try in the book to be very careful because I knew it would be controversial because it has been, to really talk through, you know, why, like both you know, how do we know that heavy drinking is bad? And then what is the kind of quality and scope of the evidence around occasional alcohol consumption? Try to set the stage a little bit around how this varies across cultures. But there's no question that that for a bunch of different reasons I think was the most was the most controversial piece. And I think when I published it at the time I probably didn't have quite this the sense of how of like what that would what would be like. So, you know, I've gotten better at dealing with controversy as I have aged, but it was very surprising the first time.

4:25 And and I will say for me, I think that was my favorite just part to read, not because I wanted to indulge in more wine, but because I never thought of it in the way that you wrote about it, like how you can't really put a woman who drinks zero, a woman who drinks two glasses per night, a woman who drinks two bottles per night into a research study and see how their kid comes out. Like it's not morally correct. So they're just kind of coming up with, yeah, you really shouldn't be drinking. Let's just cut it all off. Yeah, I think it's a combination of like it's hard to do the studies that we would want and we're sort of extrapolating down in a way that may actually reflect the sort of right the right way to think about how biology and the data works.

5:10 So obviously since you came out with the book, a lot has changed, especially around social media and people are getting their sixty second reels and panic headlines. if you were to rewrite Expecting Better for a Mom to Get Most Out of their pregnancy, maybe what chapter would you change the most and what held up better than you expected to kind of put into those real R E E L videos to get people's attention. It's so interesting. So you know, I have updated the book a bunch of times in the past. It was published originally in twenty thirteen, so right at the beginning of the social media. And so I've I've updated a bunch.

5:51 And and I will say some of those updates feel to me like they're like they're in some way driven by Instagram. So at some point I had to put in all the stuff about skincare and Botox because that was like people were just like, What about Botox? Which I don't didn't know. I mean, I guess we had that in twenty thirteen. I just said but it wa I feel like it wasn't as openly talked about as think it's because our faces weren't on Instagram. You I think when you doing your face on the on the thing all the time, you're always like, what could I fix it though? so I I have sort of updated that. I will say I think the thing that resonates with the book still that when I read it, I'm struck by my former self is this feeling that think I I get I can see how like frustrated I was at the time when I read it.

6:39 It's like quite raw. Relative to the way I write now, which is like with the benefit of like more hindsight. Like I, you know, I'm I'm a little more I'm not in the moments the way that I was when I was writing when I was writing the book. And I think that's a very important part of the book because I think the fe those feelings are so raw when you're when you're pregnant and and I wouldn't want to get rid of that. I don't know. You know, many of the like individual pieces of advice translate quite well to Instagram. You know, it's a little harder to translate, like, here's how you should structure your thoughts about this. But I have to I probably won't put this part in there, but I do have to tell you a really funny story because the one part of this is like a little whatever. But I went out to dinner with my friends and my one b one faked her pregnancy, a girl that I know personally, and the other girl was my is my best friend and was very pregnant.

7:29 And the Girl who was faking her pregnancy ordered a glass of wine. And so my friend Carly was like, I'll order wine if if Erin is ordering wine. And then we find out she faked her whole it was a whole controversial thing. It was it was a really weird situation that I never thought existed. But anyway, I said to her, Carly, yeah, I said, Don't worry, Emily Oster said it's okay to have wine and you're a good have real pregnancies. Yeah, with a real pregnancy. You're okay, you're okay. But I th I I thought I had to tell you that story. That whole thing is I could talk another That's crazy. Yeah, it was the craziest thing ever. But anyway, that was a fun fact for you. Anyway, but I won't put that in there.

8:09 so for an anxious mom at two AM, why do you think that numbers are more comforting than someone just saying, don't worry about it? So one thing is I think when you're anxious at 2 a.m., the internet rarely tells you not to worry about it. And so that's unfortunately that's not usually a response you get. But I I think that for a certain set of people, and certainly I am in this camp, and I think as you my guess is you are too, you know, seeing like numbers and something concrete is is helpful in dialing down anxiety because telling someone don't worry about it sort of implies like I wouldn't worry about it. It's like okay, but how do I know that you and I are like the same in terms of how much we worry about different things.

8:54 And so I think to say, you know, here's the actual risk of this and you can decide if that's the kind of risk that you want to engage with or like or worry about or or not, it that kind of control and ownership is part of what delivers for many of us the potential little bit of calm that we try to I know, and I'm such a rule follower. So, like if someone tells me, you shouldn't have this, and that's again why I feel like your book was so comforting, because I was like, Okay, this is what not just like you know, and moms obviously that's how we survive is advice from other moms, but seeing the data was super helpful in that, you know, way.

9:35 has there ever been though a parenting decision where the number said one thing but your mom got said another and you ignored the data? I all the time. I mean, like all the time is a little it's like a little strong. but I I do think there are again, there's almost nothing where it's like the data is so clear that you would like have to do that and only a crazy person wouldn't. And so there are plenty of cases where there we'd say, you know, well, there's a sm small benefit in this, it's small, you know, this other people would make different choices, and I made, you know, one choice because that was the thing that worked for our for our family, especially as my kids have gotten older. There are a lot of things where, you know, I I think you have to be sensitive to like what is working for your kid and recognize that you something could work on average and could work less well for one kid than than another.

10:26 And and there are places there where, you know, like the data says that when you're trying to get your kid to eat more vegetables, you shouldn't like incentivize them. I do some. With my older kids, I do some incentivi I have I have aired into incentivization at various times because I think in some cases with my family that is the right choice. Yeah, and you ha and every kid is totally different. Every kid's different. Really, truly. It is wild and you do, you know, you gotta do what you gotta do, I always say. so when you hear, you know, this food, this product, this milestone will ruin your kid, what do you think someone sh what are maybe three questions that someone should ask before you start spiraling after maybe doing one of those things that you're saying you shouldn't?

11:18 Not you. First of all I wouldn't even before you even ask anything, I would just remind yourself, no single decision is going to ruin my child because there are no decisions like that. And when we say, we tell people like the first three years are so important. And the data shows the first three years are crucial. That's true. And what that means is kids in the first three years of life, they really need a stable place to live, enough to eat, someone who loves them, you know, and like a warm place to sleep, things that the people who are asking that question. They have already delivered those. And so we're really like, there's unfortunately a tremendous amount of inequality and a lot of kids aren't getting those things. We should think about those kids. But once you're like delivering all that stuff, all of these individual things.

12:02 Did I rush my kid out the door? Did I give them the right? Did I give them too much protein? This is like a new thing people are asking me. Like, am I giving my toddler too much protein? I was like, I don't even know what that means. Like your toddler eat protein? my God. First the adults, now the kids. popcorn. I hear that's right. So like all of these individual things. So I think the first thing I would tell people is like the just try to remind yourself like, no, that's not the one decision. And then I think the second the second thing would just say, you know, where does this come from? Where is this, is there actually am I hearing anything at all that sounds like evidence or anything? and and then, you know, just how like how in how important could this possibly be?

12:46 And There's al answer is almost always like could not possibly be important. Yeah. I always see in like the mom groups where they'll say, you know, one mom said, I just lost it on my ch my two and a half year old. I screamed at her, did I ruin my child? And I'm like, my gosh, no, you did not ruin your child from one instance. and I just maybe think how much pressure people are putting on themselves to be this perfect parent. I think we have gotten to a place where people see like every opportun every interaction with their kid feels like an opportunity to like fuck it up forever. Yeah. And that's really sorry, I don't know if I can swear on can I swear on your show? It's where on your show.

13:29 so anyway, we've gotten to place where everybody thinks that that every interaction is this opportunity to mess everything up, and that's just not like this isn't the way it works. Yeah. No, yeah. so the holidays are coming up. I read the parent data piece on the Halloween candy and you know, parents are worrying about sugar ultra processed food and dyes. We're coming up and I mean my kids still have buckets and buckets of Halloween candy and you know, Christmas coming really isn't gonna be gonna be any better. what do you do? Do you how do you do it with your kids? Do they eat freely? Do you trade it? Like what what are things that parents should, yeah, realize about it? I think that, you know, look, let me tell you I'll tell you, I mean I mean to tell you what I do with my kids, but let me t say sort of overarching.

14:16 Anything is basically fine here. You know, you like but you should decide what your rules are and how that fits in with the other choices that make for your family and then you should implement those rules and hold the boundary. So the thing that I think makes this most uncomfortable for parents is when you kind of don't decide up front what it is or you have trouble following through on it. And then it like becomes every night we're arguing about like exactly what you're allowed to have and should we throw it away and what should we do with it. And so I think, you know, thinking up front about like what are the guidelines going to be and then implementing them is almost always like a good Parenting strategy for lowering conflict, even if you're having some conflict at the beginning, right? If you're telling your kid, like, you know, at the end of like at Thanksgiving, we're throwing away the Halloween candy, and that is the rule.

15:00 And I've decided they're gonna be pissed. But if you hang on to that, you know, then they're only gonna be pissed once. At some point they're gonna be pissed. Might as well collapse it altogether. What do we do? we I actually let one my oldest kid doesn't have any Halloween candy. My younger one, I have allowed to keep. the Halloween candy at a very low rate of consumption, pretty much indefinitely. so the rules are around the rate of consumption, not like what particular thing he's consuming. So it just sits around and I think eventually it will start molding and then I guess we'll have to throw it away. Yeah, I know. I feel like by the time Valentine's Day comes, I'm like, all right, all the candy's out.

15:40 Let's get the new year candy. It's gonna go. so I also I teach seventh through twelfth grade health and phys ed and I so I have to ask you this one. You have supported bell to bell phone bans in schools and from the data, what are phones actually doing to learning and attention and what can parents do at home even if their school won't act? And I do want to say our school did act this year. We have zero phones, and I cannot begin to tell you how much better it is this year. Yeah. So I think that's a really important point because in discussing these phone bands, which like I, as you said, like I am a huge fan of and I have been talking about in writing.

16:22 I was looking back at something like since, you know, mid 2024, just like do we have to have these? and I I actually think that so far, you know, some of the evidence we have gotten about like learning and test scores, like isn't Isn't overwhelming. we may get more of that over time. But you know, knowing what I know about how hard it is to move school test scores, I actually don't think we're likely to see the impacts delivered in like all the kids are seven moving up seven center deviations in proficiency or whatever. Like, that's that's not a realistic expectation. What I think we should focus on, and is exactly the experience that I have had as an educator, that I have seen from my kids, that I've heard from my kids, that I have heard from teachers, is like. not having a distracting television screen in front of every child at every time, that makes the school experience much better.

17:09 And it makes kids' interactions with each other better. It makes them easier to teach. It makes them more focused. Like there is just no reason to have this. And we sort of got, I think by accident into this idea that we should have phones. But if you sort of started from scratch and you said like, you know, well, is this a good idea? No. Right. It's definitely not a good idea. And so I think the bar should be like this it should be the default. So I think all schools really like need to think about this as a default. And I I will say when you talk to even kids in schools that have had these bands, even though they are often quite resistant initially, the like later outcome kids will be like, Yeah, it's actually really nice that like I'm talking to my friends at lunch. We're not just all on our phones.

17:51 so you know what I think the main thing parents can do is like continue to advocate with their schools and their school districts and their states. I think we'll see a lot of I would, you know, maybe half of the states now, maybe more already have these bands. I think we'll we'll kind of get the the my guess is the rest of them will come will come through on that just given the popularity. and then I think it's it's worth asking also as a as a parent, okay, if we recognize that, you know, not being on our devices is part of how humans interact better face to face, you know, do I want to set some kinds of restrictions like that at home? You know, generally. kids aren't sleeping enough and phones should be out of the bedrooms at night. But also I think there's a maybe a more a stronger parallel for something like family meals or, you know, like what are we, do we have some time as a family, different parts of the day where we say, like, you know, no phones at the table, like everybody's gonna be looking at each other.

18:45 it doesn't have to be the whole day. You don't have to brick your phone when you get home, but but figuring out what are those times that are going to be focused, I think most families will find that's really helpful. Yeah. And I even noticed like for a while when I would walk into a classroom, it actually was like silent because everybody's like on their phone or on their computer or whatever, have their headphones in. And so it's so nice this year to see the kids. I'm like having to tell the kids, Hey, be quiet. I'm like, this is great. Yeah, it's it's interesting. My daughter has never, my older one is a sophomore in high school, and she has like her school had a ban in through eighth grade. And then when she her ninth grade year was the first year that they had a ban in the high school too.

19:28 Okay. So she's actually never had phones. And one day last year, like at the very end of the school year, they let them have their phones for the day, like because it was like testing or whatever. Right, right. And she came home, she was like, That's terrible. Yeah. Like at lunch, everyone was just on their phones. Like, I'm so glad. That that was not the whole year. And I was like, yes. So important for them to build those communication skills. well, that's good that you agree with it too. so you you also have the family firm. And one of the biggest themes around that is intentionally around time, which is the biggest thing that I hear from parents, choosing what sport, which activities, which routines fit your family's core priorities instead of just doing what everybody else is doing, which is really the pressure that I'm having as a mom of a four and five year old, which is wild to me.

20:17 as a runner and busy professional yourself, how do you personally protect your own non negotiables when the family calendar starts overflowing? And maybe what advice do you have for the parents who are feeling anxious around an overly crowded calendar? Sorry, that was wild. I think this is small question. you know, look, I think there is a lot of value in you know deliberate planning around many of these choices. And I think often what happens when people say, like, we're totally overwhelmed, like we're doing too much, is that each of those decisions was kind of a marginal decision. And you find yourself at the end, like the the sum of all the decisions is not where you wanted to land, but somehow each decision came in at a time in which we couldn't say no to that one.

21:07 And, you know, so I I think to to sort of to ask yourself, okay, like what's a good time for us to step back and ask just like how do we want the days to look? How do we what are the things we want to prioritize? What's really important to our family? And then how do we build sort of from those pillars into the things that that we're gonna do? And to recognize that that is going to both evolve over time and also involve some trade-offs. Like if you want your kid to get enough sleep, that may mean limiting some activities. And you will have to decide like which of those things is more important. And different people will come down differently. But I think it's a mistake to not pretend it's a to not pretend it's a trade-off.

21:48 And when you're having those conversations, what is important to parents and what is important to like the other all of the people in the household is also like a really important is a really important thing. I will say this is for me the like on the running stuff it's gotten much easier and the kids are bigger because like I just run in the morning Yeah off to school and I don't have to drop them off and Yeah. That's what I was gonna ask you next before we kind of round it off. you are a runner. you're you love to run. And how did you I I a lot of times parents they feel the guilt around making time for themselves for exercising and and I obviously love to run as well and my mom is a runner and she's run, you know, since we were little.

22:31 How can how did you manage that around a growing family? So I didn't used to run as much. you know, my kids are little, I I ran less. I I think I have always found this to be a practice that serves me in different ways at different times. and I do think that it is easier than some other hobbies to defend to defend. Yeah. Like almost to yourself. Not that I think you should have to. I actually like I would love if people could just be like, yeah, you I like, I need some time for myself and this is the thing I like to do and whatever it is. I have a really hard time with that. And to be able to say like this is like go well I gotta run because it's like exercise.

23:15 And I think when they were younger, that was like, okay, look, you know, like movement is important for health. This is part of investment in my health. As the kids have gotten bigger and as I have run more, I think we've gotten to a point where like it's difficult to defend. You know, like nobody's like, going from like 50 to 55 miles a week. Like that's the thing that's gonna help. Be like, I am running too much to defend it with health. But at this point, the kids are bigger and I actually feel like there's a lot of value then to be like, this is something that's really important to me. And I really like it. And it's like something that I like to do. And so that's Yeah. And that's what I always say. It sets a good example. And I know my mom had always prioritized running, even, you know, when my brother is ten years younger than me.

23:57 And so that's when like the jogging strollers really started coming out. And so she would, you know, run forever with him. And I've been lucky enough to do that with Sorry. Do you I You when I th I love the jogging stroller as like a stroller and I do love it as a jog I mean, I've done five K's with the jogging stroller, not fast, but this year I'm not really sure what to do because we do a Thanksgiving 5K every year and my kids are like too heavy for me to push them both, but they're not old enough to run a 5K, so I'm like, I think I'm just gonna have to like really just suck it up. But I do love I do love it.

24:37 I have a single and a double bob and I just I could not get into the No. I did not like it. Did like it. just like it's it's really hard. but I feel like I don't I'm I was never fast runner and I was really I mean, I did do the New York City marathon, but I was n never like a someone going out for like time. It's more just like leisure. So I think that was easier for me to just be like, my god, I'm gonna do a twelve, thirteen minute mile today, I guess, but I'm trying my best, you know. Dragon Stroller. All right. But yeah, you gotta fit you gotta fit it in where you where you kinda like maybe a year away from maybe you're like I your six year old could do a five K.

25:21 Yeah, she will be able to. I think next year she'll definitely she did do a couple of mile runs with me. so hopefully next year. But my son is like a a stroller prince. Literally, he'll just be like we'll go out for a walk. He's like, I'll just go in the stroller. I don't even need to put my shoes on. I'm like, okay, whatever. I need to get out, so why? Yeah. He loves it. See they and they both fall asleep in that double the double bob. They can fall asleep like that in it. It's like so comfortable. So that's my positive thing for that. Anyway. let's go into the overrated, underrated game. So I'm gonna ask you a couple questions and you're gonna tell me if it's overrated or underrated.

26:03 morning family meetings ver morning family meetings versus the eight p.m. post bedtime debriefs. Which one is overrated? Which is underrated? I think that any any meetings are underrated. You should always be meeting more than you are, probably for most people. But I would say that the morning meeting is underrated because you're always better off. You're always better in the morning. Yeah. Post bedtime check in people are tired. how about tracking running cadence and heart rate zones? Do you think that's overrated or underrated? I think that's overrated for almost everybody. screen time guilt for kids under five. overrated.

26:43 You shouldn't be that guilty. Yeah. a fifteen minute do nothing buffer in the family calendar. Ooh, underrated. That's a good idea. I like that. Yeah, love that. I need to do that. I always say like when I say I'm doing nothing, that actually means like I don't want to do something with you with you. I wanna just do nothing. I've I've put it in my schedule to do nothing. so I think it definitely I agree. well, thank you so much. This was such a great conversation. And I have one last question. If a brand new anxious mother is listening right now, what's a single core message that you'd want her to take from this conversation?

27:24 Or maybe you didn't say it yet. You're doing great. You're doing great. I think people could remind themselves of that more. Yes. I think we all need that reminder because I know that it is many of us are questioning so much about just everyday things. No there's no rule well, there's your book, but there's no other books to I mean, no, you know, there's books that people write, but there's, you know, there's no right way to do parenting. So I think that's great. Amazing. Yeah. I can't I really can't thank you enough. This was like meeting some I I'm so like grateful to meet you and talk to you and really like I tell everybody about your book.

28:06 so this is definitely one of those interviews I was like, my gosh, this is like meeting, you know, a superstar that really helped me through my pregnancy and just making everything feel better in an already chaotic time in 2020. Well, I'm so happy that it was helpful. Yeah. all right. Well, thank you to everyone for listening and spending time with us on the Running Wine Mom. Don't forget to subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with someone who needs to hear it. You can follow me on Instagram at the Running Wine Mom underscore and Emily, where can the listeners find you? You can find me also on Instagram at Prof. Perfect. Yeah. And I will link all of that.

28:47 so thank you so much for joining us today. Remember, you were strong, you were capable, and you are all amazing. Until next time, keep running, see, keep sipping, keep looking at the data and embracing the joy of motherhood. Cheers, and I will be back next Tuesday. Thank you. my gosh, I love your outro. Thanks.